Microbial cell free DNA sequencing is increasingly used for diagnosis of infection but few studies describe its utility in real-world settings. We performed a single-center retrospective case series of microbial cell free DNA testing using the Karius assay from 29 patient samples to define the clinical reasoning and the impact of testing. Indications fell into 3 categories, identifying a causative pathogen in patients with an infectious syndrome and negative microbiologic workup (15/29, 52%), seeking another pathogen when organisms identified by traditional diagnostics failed to explain the clinical presentation (9/29, 31%) and to "rule out" infection in patients with nonspecific symptoms and negative microbiologic workup (5/29, 17%). Clinical impact was positive in 13/29 (45%) and all were for patients with high pretest probability for infection. Impact was negative in 3/29 (10%) cases. There was no impact in 15/29 (52%) cases. Further work is needed to define the optimal timing accounting for test performance, and patient characteristics.